Question 1

Tip More Selectively: pros and cons

Accepted Answer

Pros: Rewards attentive service; Preserves gratuity meaning; Avoids unnecessary payments. Cons: Can feel inconsistent; May irritate workers; Requires judgment calls.

Question 2

Follow Standard Percentages: pros and cons

Accepted Answer

Pros: Simple to apply; Matches expectations; Supports service workers. Cons: Can be expensive; Not always justified; Extends tipping culture.

Question 3

Reduce Tipping Expectations: pros and cons

Accepted Answer

Pros: Cuts hidden costs; Pressures wage reform; Simplifies transactions. Cons: Lowers worker income; Breaks local norms; Hurts good service.

Question 4

Tip Only When Prompted: pros and cons

Accepted Answer

Pros: Easy to follow; Fits card payments; Avoids awkward refusals. Cons: Prompts can overreach; Encourages pressure; Lacks consistency.

Question 5

Treat Tipping as Optional: pros and cons

Accepted Answer

Pros: Clear principle; Prevents tip fatigue; Flexible by context. Cons: Ambiguous boundaries; Can reduce income; Less predictable etiquette.

Has tipping gotten out of hand, and what is the proper etiquette now?

Key Arguments

Tip More Selectively

Follow Standard Percentages

Reduce Tipping Expectations

Tip Only When Prompted

Treat Tipping as Optional

Community Opinions